10 min read | 2873 words | 0 views | 0 comments
For most of the history of the telephone, regular delivery of the latest phone book was an expected public service of the telephone company, and being listed in the phone book was often a rite of passage, a confirmation of your independence (and even importance). Over the last two decades, broadband connectivity has rendered the phone book less essential to people's lives than it once was, and these once-essential household staples have increasingly been seen as nuisances, unopened in household recycling. For this reason, consumers were allowed to "opt out" of what was previously universal delivery. More recently, those who still wish to receive print directories are now required to "opt in", with "opt out" being the default in many areas. And finally, in some places, we are entering the final phase, the inability to opt in altogether, as some print directories are discontinued.
These changes have been met with little fanfare, and they differ from state to state. Over the last nine months, I've spent some time investigating changes in directory publishing in the U.S., which have silently changed the rules in many areas without any notice to consumers. Two points before I continue. First, I'm specifically talking about the White Pages directory, which contains residential and business listings by name; not the Yellow Pages, which contains businesses listed by category, and is funded by the many advertisements which appear within its pages. Secondly, the directories themselves are still published in their original format electronically; the White Pages itself is not going away, at least for now. What's been changing in the past year or so is that the White Pages are no longer available in print to many consumers.
Before we continue, some background is necessary. Most telephone companies in the U.S. have long since outsourced the printing and publishing of directories to third-party companies. Phone companies still provide the raw directory listings (provided you don't opt for an unlisted telephone numbers), which go to the nationwide 411 database and the directory publishers. In most places, particularly in ex-Bell RBOC territories, Dex Media (now part of Thryv) is the actual publisher of both Yellow Pages and White Pages directories. You can go to TheRealYellowPages.com to view the directories online, or you can call (844) 339-6334 to order the Yellow and White Pages directories in your area, free of charge.
At least, that's how it's supposed to work. The Yellow Pages, funded by advertising, should still be available nationwide. The White Pages, however, doesn't contain advertising, and thus has a different business model. Individual phone companies are responsible for funding the directory to allow publishers like Dex to cover the costs of printing and mailing. For example, even though I live in Verizon territory, and Verizon outsources directory publishing to Dex, they still bear the costs.
One change that Dex has made in response to declining directory usage is to reduce the frequency of directory publishing. Directories, which used to be distributed annually, or even more frequently than that, are now generally published on 18 to 24-month publishing cycles (mind you, this includes the electronic versions as well as the print versions, which are more or less identical). This means if you happen to be unlucky enough to move not long after a directory has been published, you might need to wait the better part of 2 years to see your phone number in the directory! Run into a new friend around town? It used to be you could say "Call me later, I'm in the book", but if you've recently moved, there's a good chance that you might not be (and depending on where you live now, you might never be).
And yes, your number should be available via Directory Assistance immediately, but Directory Assistance isn't free anymore.
Another change is that White Pages directories, for some time now, have been printed purely on demand. Supposedly, Yellow Pages printing is still done in batches, and thus might reach you sooner, but individual White Pages directories are only printed when requested. Both directories are generally printed by Quad Graphics in Wisconsin and mailed to wherever you live, nationwide.
Back in July 2025, I called Dex to order the latest directories in my area, since that was when the new phone book was supposed to come out. Having moved in the two years prior, I was excited that I would finally get to see my name in print in the phone book after waiting an awfully long time. I had no trouble ordering the Yellow Pages, which is what the agent assumes you want when you call in, but when I then requested the White Pages, as I had in the past, I was told that the White Pages was "no longer available" as it was "available online". Sounds like a reasonable explanation, except it's not correct. I inquired about availability of the White Pages in several other markets around the country, and was told that it was available in some markets (only for one more publishing cycle, in some) and not available in others, with seemingly no rhyme or reason to this.
I decided to investigate what was really going on. What was the real reason I could no longer order a directory in my area? Within the industry itself, there is very little knowledge or awareness of what is going on. The frontline reps at Dex don't actually know anything, and parrot the baseless claim that it's migrated online, which is baloney, because both directories have been available online for a while, and in certain markets, I could still get a directory (at least, if I lived there). The supervisor at Dex told me that Verizon had discontinued the White Pages, which is also baloney, given that Dex was still publishing them electronically, and Verizon doesn't publish directories at all, either. Calling Verizon, nobody there seemed to have any more information, other than "Verizon doesn't publish directories anymore; this is handled by a third-party company". So, both companies were pointing the finger at the other, a classic example of phone companies refusing to take responsibility for their role in an incident.
Eventually, I was escalated high enough within Dex to speak to a native English speaker at Thryv; she didn't know the exact deal behind what was going on either, but she did offer to print a version of the directory on her home printer and mail it to me[1]. She then connected me with her boss, who happened to know the right contact at Verizon, who was responsible for the relationship with Dex and although he didn't know all the answers initially, helpfully offered to do some research and get back to me.
It was clear by this point that whatever the reason was was likely something that differed on a state-by-state basis. There is no nationwide mandate for phone book delivery (or even to be able to order one). Many states do have rules governing the distribution and availability of White Pages directories, but these differ widely. For example, Pennsylvania residents had the right to order a directory, at least until the beginning of 2026. California, as usual, is an interesting case study. Back in 2011, the California PUC considered, and ultimately granted, Verizon's petition to move from "opt out" to "opt in" White Pages delivery. White Pages directories are considered part of "basic service" requirements in California, codified in D.96-10-166 back in 1996:
In 1996, this Commission adopted rules implementing The Moore Universal Telephone Service Act of 1987. As part of that proceeding, we held that carriers providing local exchange residential telephone service must provide a free white pages directory to their customers as part of basic telephone service, stating: "Telephone customers have become accustomed to receiving a free white pages directory and yellow pages directory every year... We shall add the free white pages directory to the definition of basic service." (D.96-10-166, Appendix B; Resolution T-17302, p. 7
The Moore Universal Telephone Service Act of 1987 seemed to provide important protections for directory availability in California. As recently as 2014, CPUC documents made reference to White Pages directories as being foundational service elements for voice service in California:
In recent ETC Resolutions, the Commission has allowed federally supported wireless service providers to deviate from the following six California LifeLine service elements:— Decision 14-01-036, p. 10
- Ability to receive free unlimited incoming calls
- Customer choice of flat rate local service or measured rate local service
- Free provision of one directory listing per year
- Free white pages telephone directory
- Free access to Directory Assistance calls
- Free access to 800 and 800-like toll-free numbers
(To clarify, the above are facets of basic traditional voice service in California to which wireless providers (which are not basic voice service providers) are not subject.)
I reached out to the CPUC Public Advisor's Office to determine how relevant the Moore Act was today. They responded as follows:
After communicating with our Communication Division, in 2011, Verizon (now Frontier) filed an application to the Commission through an advice letter requesting to satisfy the requirement to provide a free published directory by notifying affected customers they could receive delivery of the directory electronically by CD-ROM or by on‑line access, unless a customer affirmatively elected to receive a traditional printed paper copy. The Commission approved Verizon's application in Resolution T-17302.
On August 16, 2016, the Commission approved Resolution T-17513, which allowed Pacific Bell, dba AT&T California (AT&T) to change its method of delivery for customer notice on the availability of residential white page directory listings by mailing postcards to each customer instead of making the business directories the vehicle of delivering such notice, as ordered by Resolution T-17302.
Back to Virginia, the domicile of my inquiry with Dex and Verizon. At first, it seemed that the law stated unequivocally that White Pages directories, as in California, were protected:
A LEC shall publish or cause to be published its customers' listing information in printed directories and shall distribute or cause to be distributed to its customers such directories at yearly intervals. — 20VAC5-428-80(A). Printed directories.
Although Verizon no longer directly publishes directories, it seemed plain enough that, having outsourced the publishing to Dex, it was still responsible for ensuring that they were printed and distributed to consumers who requested them.
During my first conversation with Todd, the Verizon contact with whom the Dex VP had put me in touch, he admitted that he wasn't sure about this, but would look into it and get back to me. True to his word, he came back with the answer: specific legal verbiage that did, in fact, authorize Verizon to stop funding White Pages printing in the state.
It really comes down to a clever loophole in Virginia state law. According to the Virginia SCC:
Chapter 2.1 of Title 56 of the Code of Virginia ("Code") became effective July 1, 2014. (Va. Code § 56-54.2 et seq.). The duties of a company that has elected to be regulated as a Competitive Telephone Company ("CTC") are set out in § 56-54.6 of the Code, and the Commission's authority over such CTCs is limited to that provided under § 56-54.5 of the Code. — Designated Competitive Telephone Companies, Virginia SCC
Competitive telephone companies, CTCs, are not to be confused with CLECs (competitive local exchange carriers). After all, Verizon, as an ILEC, is not generally thought of as a competitive phone company — ILECs are geographic monopolies, unique in their operation and power. This is where this is a slight twist:
In addition, § 56-54.3 of the Code provides in part: [a]ny telephone company meeting the definition of a competitive telephone company may elect to be regulated as a competitive telephone company pursuant to the provisions of this chapter by providing written notice to the Commission of such election. The election shall be effective 30 days after receipt of the notice by the Commission unless (i) the Commission notifies the electing telephone company within that 30-day period that the telephone company does not meet the definition of a competitive telephone company and (ii) the Commission then commences a proceeding to challenge the election. — Designated Competitive Telephone Companies, Virginia SCC
Read that again. The duties of a company that has elected to be regulated as a CTC are set out in § 56-54.6 and the Commission's authority over such CTCs is limited to that provided under § 56-54.5 in addition, [a]ny telephone company meeting the definition of a competitive telephone company may elect to be regulated as a competitive telephone company.
So, any phone company in Virginia, even an ILEC, may voluntarily elect to be considered a "competitive telephone company" (not to be confused with a CLEC), in which case the Commission will have no authority whatsoever to regulate it, except as defined in § 56-54.5! And sure enough, both Verizon Virginia and Verizon South ILEC are CTCs in Virginia. How about that?
So, what exactly does § 56-54.5 require? As you might imagine, not much. You can read it in its entirety in a single page. All the other state laws on the books? Completely irrelevant, superseded by the CTC law. Unsurprisingly, there's no mention of directories in § 56-54.5, which is why Verizon can legally prevent them from being printed in the state.
The Virginia SCC (Virginia's equivalent to a PUC or PSC in other states) confirmed as much that, short of being completely without service, the SCC is completely powerless to regulate phone companies at all. Verizon could charge hundreds of bucks for dial tone and get away with it (which, considering just the other week I got a bill insert informing me of rate increases, and other goings-on in the industry, is not as improbable as one might think). The Virginia Legislature introduced a massive loophole in 2014, and Verizon is sure as heck taking advantage of it.
The amendments to Title 56 were passed by Virginia in 2014, as House Bill 774 and Senate Bill 584. SB 584 was introduced by Dick Saslaw, who has been criticized for being quite cozy with Dominion Energy, pushing legislation to allow Dominion to charge exorbitant rates that would yield Dominion hundreds of millions in annual profits. And tricky Dick's #2 donor, after Dominion? You guessed it, Verizon, with almost $300,000 in donations. Timothy D. Hugo, who introduced HB 774, also benefitted from more than $50,000 in donations.
While corruption may have killed the White Pages in Virginia, other states will likely face similar issues in the years to come, if they don't already. Even California, the only state that has so far stood up to AT&T's bullying, is no friend to the consumer. In its current COLR Modernization Proposal, CPUC staffers have entertained industry desires to gut requirements for printed directories and even Directory Assistance:
In D. 96-10-066, the Commission set forth several basic service elements ensuring access to various directory services. The Commission subsequently reafirmed and consolidated these into a single element in D. 12-12-038, requiring COLR providers to ofer directory assistance, one free white pages listing, and a free white pages directory. There is little evidence that access to directory services is essential to participation in modern society CD staff fnd that the ability to look up telephone numbers and other information through online tools and applications means that access to directory services is not a necessary element of Modernized Essential Service. Californians who don’t have access to a broadband connection or cell phone coverage can dial 211 to access information, referrals, and essential community services Independent Small LECs state that directory services and the requirement to provide "white pages" listings are outdated and no longer needed. CD Staff agree that this element is not necessary and recommend not including this element of basic service as an element of Modernized Essential Service. — Carrier of Last Resort and Network Modernization Staff Proposal (R.24-06-012), December 2025, p. 54-56
Ultimately, this is about much more than just White Pages directories. These directories are still critical resources for many who rely on or prefer them, but beyond that, they are a victim in the losing battle over telecom regulation and consumer protections, an example of yet another thing that falls by the wayside when powerful utilities that were historically regulated in exchange for their monopoly status are able to bribe legislators into effectively completely deregulating them. The White Pages are the latest victim in this battle, and unfortunately, they won't be the last one.
[1] In the end, I ended up taking up the offer of the Dex employee, who generously mailed me a printed and stapled printout of my local White Pages. This was a "one time courtesy" at her own expense, so one way or another, this may end up being my last "White Pages".
[2] If you are a Verizon customer who has been denied a print White Pages Directory, you likely do not have much recourse. I suggested they offer free directory assistance in areas where they prevent customers from obtaining a printed White Pages directory, but absent any requirement to do so, they certainly won't. Todd suggested reaching out to the Verizon Center for Customers with Disabilities which facilitates no charge directory-assistance and operator services for eligible customers with disabilities or seniors (65+). No accomodations for directory-deprived customers currently exist, but it's worth asking for one; you can reach them at (800) 974-6006, M-F 8:30-5 ET.
Log in to leave a comment!